Re: Top 18 Spiel des Jahres Winners

A couple of weeks ago, Ryan and Drew over at Sword, Board, and Pen put together a couple of lists of their Top 18 Spiel des Jahres Winners. It’s an interesting challenge, and great to read their thoughts.

There’s only one problem: both their lists are wrong.

Or at least according to my tastes.

Spiel des Jahres winners from left to right: Azul, Codenames, Village, Kingdomino, Carcassonne, Agricola, Broom Service
I learnt the rules to Broom Service last weekend. It’s only a matter of time.

Here’s my take:

  1. Dominion – Easily the smartest game on the list. Although my enjoyment doesn’t come from the first play, but in subsequent plays with the same market. Experimenting with your strategy and seeing what works, and what doesn’t brings me an immense amount of gratification.
  2. Azul – I agree with Drew here, in that Azul is second best. I’ve played it a lot more times since I wrote my review and it still holds up.
  3. Agricola – A worker placement about farm life, and keeping your family alive. The only thing I’m not a huge fan of is the upkeep between turns. Also, it’s pretty punishing if you mess up. Which is what your opponents are constantly trying to do.
  4. 7 Wonders – Slick card drafting with a city building veneer. A great way to spend 30 minutes. And plays up to 7 players. I’ve moved a bit away from card drafting games as they don’t elicit the feeling I want from my gaming sessions. As usually everyone gets trapped in their own world and doesn’t interact with the rest of the table.
  5. Carcassonne – A tile placement game that’s placed a tile in my heart. Charming, easy to play, and allows you to play the way you want. If it’s with family, have a relaxing time building. If it’s with your wife, thwart her every move. Destroy her! Carcassonne allows for both.
  6. Dixit – Guess which card is mine. This game is wholly dependant on the group, and for me has been a huge hit. Or a wet blanket. Read more in my review.
  7. Ticket to Ride – Route building in it’s most simplistic form. It’s the only game on this list I haven’t owned. But the times I’ve played it have been pretty fun albeit a bit light. I’ve played Ethnos which has a similar drafting mechanism, and I think I’d rather play that.
  8. Codenames – A word association party game. Easy to learn. Really fun to watch someone struggle to come up with a good clue. Likewise it’s awesome when a good clue gets pulled off. Or a team strikes out with the assassin. Great game.
  9. Camel Up – A betting game on crazy camels. It’s dumb fun. You never know who’s going to win. But you’re going to guess anyway. Always have a good time with this one.
  10. Village – A worker placement game about making your townspeople successful before they die. This is up there with Agricola in terms of heaviness. I’ve only played it a couple of times, and I remember thinking it was OK. However, I’ve been meaning to confirm that opinion for a while.
  11. Kingdomino – A tetromino laying game, where the goal is to make the best pattern. It’s quick and not offensive. Doesn’t have the strategic depth of any of the games so far. But it plays a lot quicker. Great for breaking out over lunch.
  12. Ice Cool – A dexterity game where you flick penguins and make sure they eat their fish! What gives Ice Cool its edge is that the penguins are weighted. Not only do they slide nicely, but the weight opens up a lot of ice cool trick shots you can perform.
  13. Colt Express – Cowboy programming. Each turn you put a card down in a pile. After the round is over, cards are drawn one at time from this pile and the actions are carried out. It’s fine but I found there’s not enough information to actually play it well. It always ends up like those old timey saloon fights. It can be fun, but definitely for the lighter audience.
  14. The Settlers of Catan – I think a lot of the fun of Settlers comes from trading. Without it, the game stagnates into a worse version of Machi Koro, which is a worse version of Space Base.
  15. Hanabi – A cooperative communication game. Whereby the difficulty is determined by the straightness of your face. I’m not a fan of this game, as it puts you in this internal struggle where to do well you want to hint to your teammates. However, the rules strictly forbid it. Someone always breaks, and when they do the game breaks with it.
  16. Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective – A choose your own adventure murder mystery. This is the kind of game that makes you question: what is a game? To me this is a puzzle, which is fine, but you don’t really have any affect on the game. Whether you choose option A, or option B doesn’t change anything. It only changes what score you’ll get at the end. This non-interactivity is not what I sign up for when buying board games.
Colt Express
I choo choo choose you

So it turns out that I haven’t actually played 18 Spiel des Jahres winners. Kudos to the guys for having played so many. Also thanks for the blog prompt, it was a fun little challenge.

Now it’s over to you.

What are your top 18?

Hope you had a great Easter. I had chocolate for breakfast and lunch. Which is both awesome, and awful. I’m going to regret today…

7 comments

  1. Oof. I just counted the expanded games, and I would have to consider another 17 games. More of the Kinderspiel winners than I would have expected, but having kids can add to that obviously.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. The first game to look at for kids that young would be Go Away Monster. It’s not on the list, but it’s a good starter game, and around 2 is probably at right. Drew has a daughter just older than that, he might be able to give better advice. My youngest is 5.

        Like

  2. Fun fact, if Ryan would have rolled any higher I would have had to do homework so that I could have actually played the ones I said I did.

    We definitely might have to revisit this with an expanded criteria!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. One problem is you were going by all of their award winners and special awards. We were just going work their original Game of the Year award.

    Several of these games were not part of our consideration. We used the Wikipedia page, but only specifically the Game of the Year under the Previous Winners. We wanted the original that dated back to 1979.

    Some of these games definitely would have placed higher on my personal list.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s